Skipping approximately 2 years, we decided to go to Essenspiel, which is THE biggest board game event in the world. Since we were entering a world-renowned convention, our hand-made, from-all-the-playtests-decaying prototype would not do anymore. Therefore, we decided to invest in our first real prototypes, made by a professional board game factory.
A friend of ours, one of the founders of Freecompany, the Slovenian company behind Eldfall Chronicles, introduced us to Unicool, a company that produces game materials. They helped us produce appropriate, production-ready files. After a lot of back-and-forth coordination, the prototypes were ready to produce, and the 10 prototypes arrived from Shenzhen a couple of months later.
Because of the fine-tuning, it was a long wait (or maybe it just felt very long), but approximately 14 days before Essenspiel they finally arrived. Opening the big box, fresh from the factory, was for me like seeing a newborn relative for the first time. It seemed like a real game, the box felt like a real game, and the smell of the components… It really felt like we’d done it.
This is now a real game.
Not just a Tabletopia version that we had set up about 2 months earlier, but a real physical board game that you can add to your shelf, next to Dune: Imperium – Uprising and 7 Wonders Duel.
But that is only the beginning. The game is still unknown to anyone outside our circles of friends. And we have 87 followers on Instagram, who are pretty much our family, friends and some people we met through student exchanges (shoutout to all my FRIENDS from Macedonia).
Oh, and Essenspiel: arriving at Hall 1 a day early to set up our booth, we were surprised to find that we were about 2 booths away from Diablo, 4 booths away from StarCraft and 6 booths away from Warhammer 40k. That triggers some mixed feelings inside your indie developer head. You are competing with THE big guns. And not far away were the Slovenians from Eldfall Chronicles, and next to us was Malediction, both of whom already have some successful campaigns behind them.
Are people even going to notice us? Around us were mostly tabletop RPGs like Doomsong and miniature war games like the ones mentioned above. We are an asymmetric deck-building eurogame-ish game. What if the people coming to the hall are only going to be searching for games unlike ours? Also, why would you buy our game if you can buy Diablo instead?
There are no big board game communities that we know of in Slovenia. Sure, you have some specialized communities built around miniature painting and D&D, then you have TCG tournaments and a Pokémon fan club, but for board games like ours? Not that we know of. For us, you are considered a board gamer if you have, I’d say, more than 9 board games at home, and most of the people who say they love board games have probably just played Catan and Activity.
On the first day of Essenspiel, a contact lens got stuck in the inner corner of my upper eyelid literally 5 minutes before we left for the convention. It would not come out, and there was just no time. It was not that bothersome, I was full of adrenaline before the event, and I did not want to waste my friends’ time before our first day of Essenspiel. The following day I woke up with a glued eye and a little bit of pus stuck to my eyelashes, and that gave me a scare. I went to the hospital, where a worker asked me if I was living in Germany. I said that I had only come for Essenspiel as an exhibitor, to which she replied: “Oh, cool.” About 15 minutes later she came back with a piece of paper and asked me to write down the name of the game.
As I was trying to remember the exact website address, she was telling me she has 200 board games at home and that she is in a WhatsApp group with 400 people, most of whom have over 1,000 board games at home. I suddenly felt like I was no board gamer at all with the 10 board games I own.
So, going back to Essenspiel: on the first day of the convention, at 10:00, my fears turned out to be completely unfounded, because visitors do their homework before Spiel. There are subreddits dedicated to the event where people analyze all the games being exhibited and make a list of the stands they’d like to visit. So, lucky for us, there are players interested in indie board games just for the sake of it. At the very start of the convention, 4 German guys came directly to talk to us and try our demo. And I really felt honoured by that. I want to say thank you to those guys, if you stumble upon this blog.
And like that we kept going for the rest of Spiel, with countless playtests, great feedback from visitors, ideas, and even people asking us if we could sell them the game right now.
However, there was one piece of feedback that stood out. A negative one. One person completely lost it when I mentioned that we had used AI as one of the tools for creating the card illustrations. They said that we should be ashamed of ourselves for doing that, and that we were effectively stealing work done by other people. And, well, after hearing that, I felt like a fraud. I am still unsure how I feel about it.
Since we understand that the use of AI is a sensitive topic for some people, in every single one of my demos I told visitors that we used AI. It was interesting to listen to a spectrum of different opinions.
After some discussion within our team, we came to some conclusions we agreed on. Most of the general population now uses AI on a daily basis, in IT, engineering, marketing and so on. What matters in our situation is that even creative industries such as advertising, architecture, fashion, film and video, music, television and radio are integrating AI. We treat it the way those industries do: as a tool. You can use it well or badly, depending on your knowledge of the work that needs to be done.
When it comes to comparing illustrators who don’t use AI with those who do, using it in the correct way can speed up their process and make their work available to a wider audience because of the lower cost of production. Who is to judge when an illustrator is not an illustrator anymore? Where do we draw the line? Should we then take away digital art, because its creators are not necessarily able to recreate it traditionally? Are people not artists anymore if they draw inspiration from AI-generated images instead of books or “traditional” digital media? An illustrator who integrates AI into their workflow will always be able to create better work than a regular guy using AI for illustrations. Some would even argue that commissioned illustrations are not necessarily art, but work that AI could help create as a shortcut, unlike high art, which can only be captured by human craziness and expression, something AI will never be able to replace.
Besides this, everyone agreed on one thing: people should be straightforward about the use of AI and label it accordingly, the same way a supermarket labels organic products that are twice as expensive as their non-organic counterparts. After that, it is up to you whether to buy it or not.
It wasn’t easy for us. We started the company as 4 young people without an income, so it was either using this new tool or nothing.
Still, the passionate negative feedback did sink in, and we decided that once we raise enough capital, we would like to work with a professional illustrator on all our future projects.